In an article entitled, “Who’s in Charge Here? The Illusions of Church Infallibility” Dr. Michael Horton writes:
In my experience with those who wrestle with conversion to Roman
Catholicism—at least those who have professed faith in the gospel, the
driving theological issue is authority. How can I be certain that what I
believe is true? The gospel of free grace through the justification of
sinners in Christ alone moves to the back seat. Instead of the horse, it
becomes the cart. Adjustments are made in their understanding of the
gospel after accepting Rome’s arguments against sola scriptura. I
address these remarks to friends struggling with that issue.
Reformation Christians can agree with Augustine when he said that he
would never have known the truth of God’s Word apart from the catholic
church. As the minister of salvation, the church is the context and
means through which we come to faith and are kept in the faith to the
end. When Philip found an Ethiopian treasury secretary returning from
Jerusalem reading Isaiah 53, he inquired, “Do you understand what you
are reading?” “How can I,” the official replied, “unless someone guides
me?” (Ac 8:30-31). Explaining the passage in the light of its
fulfillment in Christ, Philip baptized the man who then “went on his way
rejoicing” (v 39).
Philip did not have to be infallible; he only had to communicate with sufficient truth and clarity the infallible Word.
For many, this kind of certainty, based on a text, is not adequate.
We have to know—really know—that what we believe is an infallible
interpretation of an ultimate authority. The churches of the Reformation
confess that even though some passages are more difficult to
understand, the basic narratives, doctrines and commands of
Scripture—especially the message of Christ as that unfolds from Genesis
to Revelation—is so clearly evident that even the unlearned can grasp
it. Continue at John Samson